Definitive All-Time Disney Original Song Bracket Battle: It's the Circle of Life

She says that movie was designed to please as many people as possible and that the music is underwhelming and overplayed.

You can arguably say that about some of Disney’s really recent films, but not Moana. I’m sorry, but she is objectively incorrect.

1 Like

The universal appeal of Moana speaks to the strength of the movie, no? It was made by a diverse team of people, including producer Osnat Shurer (Israeli), the Honolulu-born identical twin writing team Aaron and Jordan Kandell, and of course a huge cast that includes the stars Auliʻi Cravalho and Dwayne Johnson.

Ask her why she hates accessible diversity?

:grin:

2 Likes

I’m going to side with CN’s wife, and extend it to Hamilton. Lin-Manuel Miranda seems like one of the nicest guys ever, but his music just doesn’t do anything for me. The lyrics are clever, but the rhythms get repetitive. The constant and-1-and-2 of “We Know the Way” is a good example.

heh she would not agree about LMM or hamilton

And here we go with the second round!

1 Seed: Let It Go – Frozen

vs

17 Seed: Let’s Go Fly a Kite – Mary Poppins

#1 Let It Go – Frozen vs. #17 Let’s Go Fly a Kite – Mary Poppins
  • #1 Let It Go – Frozen
  • #17 Let’s Go Fly a Kite – Mary Poppins
0 voters

9 Seed: Prince Ali - Aladdin

vs

25 Seed: Supercalafragilisticexpialidocious – Mary Poppins

#9 Prince Ali - Aladdin vs. #25 Supercalafragilisticexpialidocious – Mary Poppins
  • #9 Prince Ali - Aladdin
  • #25 Supercalafragilisticexpialidocious – Mary Poppins
0 voters
1 Like

4 Seed: Gaston - Beauty and the Beast

vs

13 Seed: Baby Mine – Dumbo

#4 Gaston - Beauty and the Beast vs. #13 Baby Mine – Dumbo
  • #4 Gaston - Beauty and the Beast
  • #13 Baby Mine – Dumbo
0 voters

5 Seed: Cruella De Vil - 101 Dalmatians

vs

12 Seed: I Wanna Be Like You – Jungle Book

#5 Cruella De Vil - 101 Dalmatians vs. #12 I Wanna Be Like You – Jungle Book
  • #5 Cruella De Vil - 101 Dalmatians
  • #12 I Wanna Be Like You – Jungle Book
0 voters

2 Seed: Can You Feel the Love Tonight – The Lion King

vs

15 Seed: One Jump Ahead - Aladdin

#2 Can You Feel the Love Tonight – The Lion King vs. #15 One Jump Ahead - Aladdin
  • #2 Can You Feel the Love Tonight – The Lion King
  • #15 One Jump Ahead - Aladdin
0 voters

Mary Poppins is going down

9b9968ccbf3160b5fe85c4dd4e5118b0

1 Like

7 Seed: Do you Want to Build a Snowman?

vs

10 Seed: When She Loved Me - Toy Story 2

#7 Do you Want to Build a Snowman? vs. #10 When She Loved Me - Toy Story 2
  • #7 Do you Want to Build a Snowman?
  • #10 When She Loved Me - Toy Story 2
0 voters

3 Seed: You’ll Be in My Heart – Tarzan

vs

14 Seed: You’ve Got a Friend in Me – Toy Story

#3 You’ll Be in My Heart – Tarzan vs. #14 You’ve Got a Friend in Me – Toy Story
  • #3 You’ll Be in My Heart – Tarzan
  • #14 You’ve Got a Friend in Me – Toy Story
0 voters

6 Seed: This is Halloween Nightmare Before Christmas

vs

11 Seed: How far I’ll Go — Moana

#6 This is Halloween Nightmare Before Christmas vs. #11 How far I’ll Go — Moana
  • #6 This is Halloween Nightmare Before Christmas
  • #11 How far I’ll Go — Moana
0 voters

Oof, holy shit that’s going to be a hard one.

1 Like

No one beats Dumbo like Gaston!

1 Like

Yeah, the heartbreak-off is brutal.

I am close to voting for Dumbo. No one sings like Gaston, but that song has way, way too much Le Fou

Somebody put this together just to spite me. I hate both of these

I seeded the 1-16 seed songs, four of each. I didn’t formally randomize or structure the songs within each seed group. I just entered them into the bracket without care and let the chips fall as they will. (17-27 seeds were formally randomized).

2 Likes